Special shoes for arthritis are 'no better than trainers' (2024)

  • Scientists found 'ugly' specialist shoes no better than regular shoes
  • Patients can spurn unsightly orthopaedic footwear in favour of trainers
  • Australian scientists studied 164 patients with osteoarthritis in their knees
  • There was no statistically significant difference between those who wore the special shoes and those who did not

By Rosie Taylor for the Daily Mail

Published: | Updated:

21 shares

12 View comments

No sacrifices: Arthritis sufferers may no longer have to sacrifice style for comfort

Arthritis sufferers may no longer have to sacrifice style for comfort.

Scientists have found 'ugly' specialist shoes were no better than regular walking shoes at helping people with arthritis in their knees.

It means patients can spurn unsightly orthopaedic footwear in favour of more fashionable structured trainers, without worrying about the impact on their joints.

For the study, Australian scientists studied 164 patients with osteoarthritis in their knees who were divided into two groups.

Participants were all given a new pair of shoes to wear for six months – one group received a specialist 'unloading' shoe designed to change the position of the foot to take weight off the knee.

Unloading shoes typically have thick, stuffed soles, particularly around the arch of the foot and wedge-shape insoles.

The other group was given a pair of walking trainers. Both pairs of lace-up black shoes looked similar and featured gel cushioning and flexible leather uppers, but only the unloading shoe was specifically structured to help with arthritis.

After wearing the shoes as often as possible for six months, around half of participants in each group saw improvements in the amount of pain they suffered and their ability to move freely.

There was no statistically significant difference between those who wore the special shoes and those who did not.

But the results did reveal around half the patients may have benefited from wearing better quality shoes than their usual footwear.

The research was published in the Annals of Internal Medicine.

RELATED ARTICLES

  • Previous
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • Next
  • Dementia's cruelest irony: a son's open account of losing... Pregnant women who take vitamins to boost their baby's... 'I'd rather do alternative medicine than go to the GP':... Me and my operation: new pacemaker can reduce high blood...
  • Common medicines including cold and flu remedies,... 'More cases of antibiotic-resistant superbug will be... The women told they're 'just stressed' when it's really... Patients who receive blood transfusions from young, female...
  • Doctors should NOT recommend e-cigarettes to smokers -... Is water the 'cornerstone' of a weight-loss diet? Obese... Get moving, stand up tall and ditch the heels:... Heart attack survivors who go on to have heart failure are...
  • 'Can't get enough of you baby': IVF clinic says vibrations... Your mother was right: You will catch your death of cold if...

Share this article

Share

21 shares

A linked editorial said the research provided 'a promising avenue for patients with knee osteoarthritis'.

The authors wrote: 'The fact that both treatment groups received new shoes and improved over the six-month study highlights the promise of simple biomechanical interventions.

'It has been said that 'Cinderella is proof that a new pair of shoes can change your life.' Wouldn't it be wonderful if a simple pair of new shoes could help patients with knee osteoarthritis?'

Australian Scientists have found 'ugly' specialist shoes were no better than regular walking shoes at helping people with arthritis in their knees

But the editorial also pointed out weaknesses in the study, including the fact researchers did not measure foot posture and gait, which could have affected how individuals improved, and that there was no control group of patients who wore their usual shoes.

Around three quarters of arthritis pain treatment effects are thought to be caused by the placebo effect.

Osteoarthritis causes joints to become painful and stiff. It is the most common form of arthritis in the UK, with around 8.75million people suffering from the condition.

Almost any joint can be affected, but it most commonly affects the knees, with 4.1million Britons having arthritis in at least one knee. Around 2.5million have the condition in their hip or hips.

One way to manage the pain of arthritis in knees is to reduce the weight that is carried through the joint. This is often managed through weight loss, using a cane, applying a knee brace which realigns the joint or using specialist footwear.

Most watched News videos

  • Apparent moment police pull out 'Abdul Ezedi's body' from the Thames
  • Meghan laughs as Michael Bublé sings My Way with re-written lyrics
  • 'Keep fighting the good fight': Prince William tells Red Cross staff
  • Navalny's widow Yulia: 'I will continue to fight for a free Russia'
  • American ballerina detained for 'high treason' in Russia
  • The late Ewen MacIntosh's iconic moments in The UK Office
  • Michael Buble re-writes My Way for Harry and Meghan
  • Wills met with cries of 'Free, free Palestine' outside Red Cross HQ
  • Police recover body of acid attack suspect Abdul Ezedi in River Thames
  • Boris Akunin: 'Putin is a man who believes in exterminating enemies'
  • Flight makes emergency landing after wing comes apart mid-air
  • Speaker Lindsay Hoyle apologises to House over procedural decision

Special shoes for arthritis are 'no better than trainers' (16)

Comments 11

Share what you think

  • Newest
  • Oldest
  • Best rated
  • Worst rated

The comments below have not been moderated.

The views expressed in the contents above are those of our users and do not necessarily reflect the views of MailOnline.

We are no longer accepting comments on this article.

Special shoes for arthritis are 'no better than trainers' (2024)

FAQs

Which shoes are best for arthritis? ›

For both women and men, experts like the fitted ankles of boots, which stay on without any help from toes. Look for chunky or wedged heels, soft uppers and adjustable laces and buckles for a customized fit.

Are there special shoes for arthritic feet? ›

Arthritic footwear should provide the following benefits:

High, wide toe box (high and wide space in the toe area) Removable insoles for fitting flexibility and the option to insert orthotics if necessary. Rocker Soles designed to facilitate ambulating (walking) and to reduce stress and pain at the ball-of-the-foot.

What are the best shoes to wear if you have arthritis in your hips? ›

Stable supportive shoes: ASICS Kayano (men and women), Merrel Jungle Moc (men), Nike Air Max 90 Ultra (women), Rockport Edge Hill (men), and New Balance 624 (women).

What shoes are best for people with rheumatoid arthritis? ›

A person with RA should look for shoes that have wide toe boxes, rocker bottoms, and soft arch support. Shoes with adjustable straps and comfortable, breathable material may also be beneficial for a person with RA. Some people with RA may also benefit from insoles.

What is the best thing for arthritis in your feet? ›

Non-steroidal Anti-inflammatory Drugs

Our doctors often recommend nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) to reduce swelling and relieve pain in foot and ankle joints affected by arthritis. NSAIDs are taken by mouth, and many, including ibuprofen and naproxen, are available over the counter.

What shoes do orthopedic surgeons recommend? ›

Klaw 528
  • Klaw 528. Best orthopedic shoe overall. ...
  • More options. Dansko Fawna Mary Jane for Women. ...
  • More options. Cole Haan Men's Original Grand Shortwing Oxford. ...
  • Hoka Bondi 8. Best orthopedic walking shoe. ...
  • More options. Puma Deviate Nitro 2 Running Shoes. ...
  • More options. ...
  • Vionic Karmelle Oxford Casual Sneaker. ...
  • Kuru Atom.
Mar 21, 2024

What makes foot arthritis worse? ›

What causes arthritis flare-ups in the feet? Most daily activities can aggravate the joints in the feet. Putting pressure or weight on the feet can trigger flares but so can resting for long periods, such as overnight. Some people experience flares in cold weather or after eating particular foods.

Are skechers good or bad for your feet? ›

As a consequence, Skechers can cause ligament and muscle stresses and strains. The memory foam could take on the 'memory' of a poor gait style causing destabilising foot, ankle, knee, hip and lower back pain.

What is the best support for arthritis in the foot? ›

There are several types of foot and ankle supports for arthritis, including orthotic insoles, ankle braces, and compression socks. The choice of support depends on the specific type of arthritis affecting your foot or ankle and your individual needs.

Is walking barefoot good for arthritis? ›

According to a study published recently in the journal Arthritis and Rheumatism, going shoeless reduces harmful joint stress in people with osteoarthritis of the knee. Osteoarthritis occurs when the cartilage that cushions joints is gradually worn down, causing inflammation and pain.

What worsens hip arthritis? ›

Avoid activities that aggravate hip arthritis, such as running, jumping and other high-impact exercises. Lifestyle modifications, such as weight loss, can help reduce stress on the hip joint.

Should you walk if you have arthritis in your hip? ›

One of the most popular forms of exercise for hip arthritis, walking is one we can and should do every day. If you are just beginning a walking program, try to take a few 10-minutes walks a day. Start by walking slowly and build your speed and distance over time.

What are the best trainers for arthritis in feet? ›

Rocker-based shoes are a popular choice for those with osteoarthritis in the foot. These shoes have a sole designed to mimic a natural rocking motion during walking. This design helps reduce the load on the affected joints and can provide substantial relief.

Which Hoka shoe is best for arthritis? ›

I find that the HOKA Bondi provides excellent support and stability. Accordingly, I have happily recommended them to friends and colleagues.” “As a Podiatric Physician and Surgeon, I am always faced with the task of helping my patients get through their exercise goals and activities of daily living.

Are memory foam shoes good for arthritis? ›

Unsupportive shoes can worsen pain in the foot and ankle. There are two important features a shoe needs to help alleviate arthritis pain: memory foam cushioning and wide width.

What is the best thing to wear for arthritis? ›

Choose loose clothing

“For trousers or skirts, it might also be worth buying clothes that have an elasticated waist. Just check the elastic isn't too tight. They'll be easier to pull on and off. “Avoid tight fitting underwear and socks too.

Are barefoot shoes good for arthritic feet? ›

Some research shows that flexibility in shoes is important if you have foot or knee pain related to rheumatoid arthritis. A flat, flexible walking shoe that feels almost like you're barefoot may be better for many RA symptoms than so-called stability shoes.

What shoes to wear to avoid foot pain? ›

Leather and canvas are usually better for foot health than synthetic materials such as vinyl or plastic. If you are going to be on your feet all day, our Southlake podiatrist recommends choosing comfortable shoes with solid support, even if they're not the most stylish options.

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Edwin Metz

Last Updated:

Views: 6178

Rating: 4.8 / 5 (58 voted)

Reviews: 81% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Edwin Metz

Birthday: 1997-04-16

Address: 51593 Leanne Light, Kuphalmouth, DE 50012-5183

Phone: +639107620957

Job: Corporate Banking Technician

Hobby: Reading, scrapbook, role-playing games, Fishing, Fishing, Scuba diving, Beekeeping

Introduction: My name is Edwin Metz, I am a fair, energetic, helpful, brave, outstanding, nice, helpful person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.